If your sink won’t drain, your toilet is overflowing, or you have no hot water, you’re probably wondering: Are landlords required to pay for plumbing in New York? You’re not alone. Thousands of tenants across New York State face plumbing issues each year—and many don’t know their rights. The good news: New York law is clear that landlords generally must maintain working plumbing. But the details matter. Let’s break down exactly what you’re entitled to, what your landlord must do, and what steps to take if they don’t.
What Does New York Law Say About Plumbing Repairs?
Under New York State law—specifically the Warranty of Habitability (Real Property Law § 235-b)—landlords must provide and maintain essential services, including safe, working plumbing. This includes:
- Hot and cold running water
- Functional toilets, sinks, showers, and bathtubs
- Proper drainage and sewage disposal
- No leaks that cause mold or structural damage
Violations of this warranty can result in rent abatement, legal action, or even HPD (Housing Preservation and Development) violations in New York City.
According to NYC’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), plumbing issues account for over 35% of all housing code violations filed annually—making it one of the most common tenant complaints.
Who Pays for Plumbing Repairs: Tenant or Landlord?
The answer depends on what caused the problem. Here’s a clear breakdown:
| Scenario | Who Is Responsible? |
|---|---|
| Clogged drain due to normal use (e.g., hair in shower) | Landlord |
| Broken pipe or water heater malfunction | Landlord |
| Toilet clogged because tenant flushed inappropriate items (e.g., wipes, toys) | Tenant |
| Damage caused by tenant negligence or intentional misuse | Tenant |
In most cases, routine maintenance and system failures fall on the landlord. As noted by the New York State Attorney General’s Office:
“Landlords are responsible for maintaining the building’s plumbing systems in good working order, regardless of age.”
For more on habitability standards, see Warranty of Habitability – Wikipedia.
What If the Landlord Refuses to Fix the Plumbing?
If your landlord ignores your request or delays repairs, you have several legal options:
Step 1: Submit a Written Complaint
Always start with a dated, written notice (email or certified letter). Describe the issue clearly and request repairs within a reasonable time (usually 24–72 hours for emergencies like no water or sewage backup).
Step 2: File a Complaint with Local Authorities
- In New York City: Call 311 or file online with HPD.
- In other counties: Contact your local code enforcement office or health department.
HPD inspectors can issue violations and even fine landlords up to $2,000 per day for unresolved serious violations.
Step 3: Withhold Rent (Carefully!)
New York allows rent withholding if the issue severely affects habitability—but you must follow strict legal procedures. Do not stop paying rent without legal advice; instead, consider placing rent in an escrow account.
Step 4: Repair and Deduct (Limited Use)
Tenants may hire a licensed plumber for emergency repairs and deduct the cost from rent—but only if:
- The issue threatens health or safety
- You gave the landlord written notice
- The cost doesn’t exceed one month’s rent
- You keep all receipts
⚠️ Warning: Misusing “repair and deduct” can lead to eviction. Consult a tenant attorney first.
Emergency vs. Non-Emergency Plumbing Issues
Not all plumbing problems are equal. New York distinguishes between emergency and routine repairs:
Emergency Plumbing Issues (Landlord must act within 24 hours):
- No running water
- Sewage backup
- Major pipe burst causing flooding
- No hot water in winter (Oct 1–May 31 in NYC)
Non-Emergency Issues (Landlord has up to 30 days):
- Slow-draining sink
- Minor leak under kitchen sink
- Dripping faucet
In NYC, landlords must provide 24/7 emergency contact info. If they don’t respond during an emergency, call 311 immediately.
Tenant Rights by Location: NYC vs. Rest of New York State
While state law applies everywhere, New York City has stricter rules:
| Requirement | NYC | Upstate/Rural NY |
|---|---|---|
| Hot water required year-round? | Yes | Only Oct 1–May 31 |
| HPD inspection available? | Yes | No; rely on county inspectors |
| Required to provide 24/7 emergency contact? | Yes | Not always required |
| Rent stabilization protections? | Applies to ~1M units | Rare outside NYC/Albany |
If you live in Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, or Albany, check your city’s housing code—many have adopted similar standards.
Common Myths About Plumbing and Landlords
Let’s debunk some widespread misconceptions:
- ❌ “If it’s in my apartment, I pay for it.”
→ Not true. Internal plumbing is part of the building’s system—landlord’s responsibility unless you caused damage. - ❌ “My lease says I’m responsible for repairs, so I have to pay.”
→ Any lease clause that waives the Warranty of Habitability is illegal and unenforceable under NY law. - ❌ “I can just fix it myself and never tell the landlord.”
→ Without notice, you risk liability if something goes wrong. Always document.
FAQ Section
Q1: Are landlords required to pay for plumbing in New York if the tenant caused the clog?
No. If the plumbing issue results from tenant misuse (e.g., flushing paper towels), the tenant may be responsible for repair costs. However, landlords still must ensure the system is restored to working order.
Q2: How long does a landlord have to fix plumbing in NYC?
For emergencies (e.g., no water, sewage backup): 24 hours. For non-emergencies: typically within 30 days, though HPD may require faster action based on severity.
Q3: Can I break my lease if my landlord won’t fix the plumbing?
Possibly. If the issue makes the apartment uninhabitable and the landlord ignores repeated requests, you may claim constructive eviction. But you must follow legal steps—do not just move out without documentation or legal counsel.
Q4: Does this apply to rent-stabilized and market-rate apartments?
Yes. The Warranty of Habitability applies to all residential rentals in New York State, regardless of rent regulation status.
Q5: What if I’m in a basement apartment or illegal unit?
Even in unregulated or illegal units, landlords must provide basic habitability, including plumbing. However, legal remedies may be more limited. Consult a tenant rights organization like Legal Aid or Met Council on Housing.
Q6: Can a landlord charge me for calling a plumber?
Only if the problem was your fault. Otherwise, no. Charging tenants for essential repairs violates NY Real Property Law § 235-b.
Conclusion
So, are landlords required to pay for plumbing in New York? In nearly all cases—yes. From leaky faucets to sewage backups, New York law places the burden of plumbing maintenance squarely on the landlord, as part of their duty to provide safe, habitable housing.
If your landlord ignores your requests, don’t stay silent. Use your rights: document everything, file complaints, and seek help from tenant advocacy groups. Your health, safety, and peace of mind are worth it.
👉 Found this guide helpful? Share it with fellow New Yorkers on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram—someone you know might be dealing with a flooded bathroom right now!
Need personalized advice? Contact the New York State Attorney General’s Tenant Helpline or NYC’s Tenant Support Unit at 311.
Leave a Reply