If you’re a DIYer tackling a plumbing repair or installing new copper pipes, you might’ve stumbled upon an old spool of 40/60 solder and asked: “Can I use 40/60 solder for plumbing?” You’re not alone. Many homeowners—especially those referencing trusted forums like TerryLove.com—grapple with this exact question. The short answer: it’s risky and often illegal. But why? Let’s unpack the facts, safety concerns, plumbing codes, and what experts (including veteran plumbers from TerryLove.com) actually recommend.
What Is 40/60 Solder—And Why Is It a Concern for Plumbing?
40/60 solder refers to a tin-lead alloy composed of 40% tin and 60% lead. This type of solder was commonly used in plumbing decades ago due to its low melting point and ease of use. However, lead is a toxic heavy metal that can leach into drinking water—especially in acidic or low-mineral water conditions.
According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), there is no safe level of lead in drinking water. Even low exposure can cause developmental issues in children, cardiovascular problems in adults, and long-term neurological damage.
💡 Key Fact: The U.S. Safe Drinking Water Act (amended in 1986 and strengthened in 2011) bans the use of lead-containing solder in potable water systems. “Lead-free” now legally means no more than 0.2% lead in solder.
For more on solder composition and historical use, see the Wikipedia entry on solder.
Can I Use 40/60 Solder for Plumbing? The Short Answer
No—you should not use 40/60 solder for any plumbing that carries drinking water.
Here’s why:
- It violates U.S. plumbing codes (Uniform Plumbing Code, International Plumbing Code).
- It risks lead contamination in your home’s water supply.
- It may void home insurance or fail inspection during resale.
Even if you’re working on a non-potable line (e.g., irrigation or drain lines), using leaded solder is strongly discouraged due to potential cross-connections or future repurposing.
What Do Experts on TerryLove.com Say?
TerryLove.com is a respected plumbing forum where licensed professionals and experienced DIYers discuss real-world plumbing issues. A recurring theme in threads about solder is clear guidance against using leaded alloys.
In a popular 2023 thread titled “Old Solder in the Garage—Can I Use It?”, a master plumber with 28 years of experience posted:
“If it says ‘40/60’ or doesn’t specify ‘lead-free,’ do not use it on water lines. Period. The health risk isn’t worth saving $8 on a roll of solder.”
Other members echoed this, noting that modern lead-free solders (95/5 or 96/4 tin-antimony/copper) perform just as well—and are code-compliant across all 50 states.
Lead-Free vs. Leaded Solder: A Quick Comparison
| Feature | 40/60 Solder (Leaded) | Lead-Free Solder (e.g., 95/5) |
|---|---|---|
| Lead Content | 60% | ≤0.2% (legally “lead-free”) |
| Melting Point | ~370°F (188°C) | ~450–470°F (232–243°C) |
| Plumbing Code Compliance | ❌ Not allowed for potable water | ✅ Fully compliant |
| Water Safety | ❌ Risk of lead leaching | ✅ Safe for drinking water |
| Ease of Use | Easier flow, smoother joints | Slightly stiffer, requires more heat |
| Price (2025 avg.) | Rarely sold; ~$8/oz if found | ~$10–12/oz |
🛠️ Pro Tip: While lead-free solder requires a hotter torch (use MAPP gas instead of propane), the learning curve is minimal. Apply flux, heat evenly, and feed solder until it flows into the joint—you’ll get clean, strong connections.
Step-by-Step: How to Solder Copper Pipes Safely (Using Lead-Free Solder)
- Gather Supplies:
- Lead-free plumbing solder (e.g., Oatey No. 95 or Harris Stay-Silv 95)
- Plumbing flux (lead-free, acid-core)
- MAPP gas torch (or propane for small jobs)
- Emery cloth or pipe cleaner
- Safety goggles & heat-resistant gloves
- Cut & Clean Pipes:
- Cut pipe squarely with a tubing cutter.
- Clean 1 inch inside and outside the pipe end with emery cloth until shiny.
- Apply Flux:
- Brush flux onto cleaned pipe end and inside fitting. Use thin, even coats—too much can cause blockages.
- Assemble & Heat:
- Insert pipe into fitting.
- Heat the fitting (not the pipe) evenly with the torch. Apply heat to the opposite side of where you’ll feed solder.
- Apply Solder:
- When flux bubbles, touch solder to the joint seam. Capillary action will draw it in.
- Use ~1/2 inch of solder per 1/2-inch joint—enough to form a small bead around the rim.
- Cool & Test:
- Let cool naturally (don’t quench with water).
- Pressure-test with water: no leaks = success!
Common Misconceptions About 40/60 Solder
- ❌ “It’s fine if I flush the line first.”
→ Lead can leach continuously, not just during initial use. - ❌ “My grandpa used it for 50 years—no problem!”
→ Historical use doesn’t equal safety. Modern science shows even low-level lead exposure is harmful. - ❌ “It’s okay for hot water lines—lead won’t leach.”
→ Heat can actually increase leaching rates, especially in soft or acidic water.
FAQ Section
Q1: Is 40/60 solder illegal to own or sell?
A: It’s not illegal to possess old solder, but it’s illegal to use it on potable water systems under federal and state laws. Retailers can no longer sell leaded solder labeled for plumbing use.
Q2: How can I tell if my solder is lead-free?
A: Check the label. Lead-free plumbing solder will clearly state “lead-free,” “for potable water,” or list composition like “95% tin, 5% antimony.” If it says “40/60,” “50/50,” or has no label—assume it contains lead.
Q3: What should I do with old 40/60 solder?
A: Do not dump it in the trash. Lead is hazardous waste. Take it to a household hazardous waste (HHW) facility. Call your local waste management authority for drop-off locations.
Q4: Can I use 40/60 solder for electrical or HVAC work?
A: Possibly—but never on refrigerant lines that could contact potable water systems. For electronics, leaded solder is still used (though RoHS restricts it in new devices). Always match solder type to application.
Q5: Does TerryLove.com recommend specific lead-free solders?
A: Yes! Members frequently recommend Oatey No. 95, Harris Safety-Silv 95, and Canfield 95-5. These are widely available at Home Depot, Lowe’s, or plumbing supply stores.
Q6: Will using lead-free solder make my joints weaker?
A: No. Modern lead-free solders meet or exceed the strength of older leaded alloys when applied correctly. Proper cleaning, fluxing, and heating are far more critical to joint integrity than solder type.
Conclusion
So, can you use 40/60 solder for plumbing? The answer is a firm no—especially if your pipes carry drinking water. Not only does it violate U.S. plumbing codes, but it also poses a real health risk to your family. Trusted sources like TerryLove.com consistently advise using lead-free alternatives, which are safe, legal, and just as effective with a little practice.
Your plumbing is your home’s lifeline—don’t gamble with outdated materials. Invest in lead-free solder, follow proper techniques, and sleep easy knowing your water is clean and code-compliant.
Found this guide helpful? Share it with a DIY friend or on social media—because safe plumbing starts with informed choices! 💧🔧
Leave a Reply