If you grew up watching The Brady Bunch, you likely adored Marcia and Jan—played by Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb, respectively. But behind the wholesome facade of America’s favorite blended family, rumors have swirled for decades about tension between the two actresses. Does Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb still hate each other? It’s a question fans have asked for years, especially as reunion specials, interviews, and social media keep the speculation alive. In this article, we’ll dive deep into the origins of their rumored feud, what each woman has said over the years, and whether there’s any truth to the idea that they still can’t stand one another.
What Started the Rumors of a Feud?
The idea that Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb disliked each other didn’t come out of nowhere. While The Brady Bunch aired from 1969 to 1974 as a picture-perfect family sitcom, off-screen dynamics were more complex. According to multiple cast memoirs and interviews, the intense spotlight on Maureen—whose character Marcia Brady famously declared, “Marcia, Marcia, Marcia!”—created subtle tensions.
Eve Plumb, who played the perpetually overshadowed middle sister Jan, reportedly felt frustrated by the disparity in fan attention. In a 2019 interview with People, Plumb admitted, “It was hard not to feel like the overlooked one. Everyone wanted to be Marcia.” McCormick, meanwhile, has spoken openly about her struggles with fame, substance abuse, and mental health during and after the show—issues that may have strained her relationships with castmates.
While neither woman has ever claimed outright hatred, their interactions over the years have been described as “polite but distant”—fueled further by tabloids and fan forums eager for drama.
Have They Ever Addressed the Feud Publicly?
Yes—both McCormick and Plumb have spoken about their relationship, though rarely in direct conversation with each other.
In her 2008 memoir, Here’s the Story: Surviving Marcia Brady and Finding My True Voice, McCormick wrote that while she and Plumb weren’t close, there was no animosity:
“We were kids doing a job. There wasn’t time for deep friendships, but there also wasn’t real conflict.”
Eve Plumb, in contrast, has been more reserved. During a 2014 appearance on The Talk, she said:
“We get along fine when we see each other. We’re not best friends, but we share a unique bond.”
Notably, both actresses participated in the 1990s Brady Bunch reunion films (The Brady Bunch Movie, A Very Brady Sequel) and the 2021 HBO Max special Dragging the Classics: The Brady Bunch. Their on-screen chemistry remained intact, and behind-the-scenes footage showed cordial, if not warm, interactions.
Still, the absence of joint interviews or social media exchanges has kept speculation alive.
Timeline of Their Public Interactions
To understand whether Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb still hate each other, it helps to look at key moments in their post-Brady Bunch relationship:
| Year | Event | Nature of Interaction |
|---|---|---|
| 1995 | The Brady Bunch Movie | Both starred; minimal joint press |
| 2000 | TV Land Awards | Appeared separately; no joint photos |
| 2011 | The Talk reunion segment | Plumb and McCormick seated apart; polite but no direct dialogue |
| 2019 | People 50th Anniversary Feature | Individual interviews; both praised the show, not each other |
| 2021 | Dragging the Classics | Shared screen time; backstage footage shows brief, friendly exchange |
This pattern suggests professional respect, not active rivalry—but also no close friendship.
What Do Castmates Say About Their Relationship?
Other Brady Bunch actors have weighed in over the years. Florence Henderson (Carol Brady) once told Entertainment Weekly:
“There was no feud. Just different personalities.”
Barry Williams (Greg Brady) noted in his memoir that McCormick and Plumb “moved in different circles” but added, “I never saw any real hostility.”
Susan Olsen (Cindy Brady), known for her candid takes, said in a 2020 podcast:
“They weren’t enemies. But they definitely weren’t hanging out after wrap party.”
This consensus among co-stars reinforces the idea that while there was no ongoing hatred, there was also no genuine closeness—a nuance often lost in sensational headlines.
For more background on the show’s legacy, see the [Brady Bunch Wikipedia page](https.
Social Media: A Window Into Their Current Relationship?
In the age of Instagram and Twitter, many fans expect stars to interact publicly. Yet, Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb have never followed each other on social media. Neither has liked, commented on, or shared the other’s posts—even during major Brady Bunch anniversaries.
McCormick (600K+ Instagram followers) frequently posts throwback photos with co-stars like Christopher Knight (Peter) and Barry Williams. Plumb (less active online) rarely posts about the show at all.
This digital silence isn’t proof of hatred—but it does suggest emotional distance that contradicts the “Brady family forever” narrative some fans cling to.
Do They Still Hate Each Other in 2026?
As of 2026, there is no credible evidence that Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb “hate” each other. The word “hate” is a dramatic overstatement often used by tabloids to generate clicks.
Instead, the truth appears to be this:
- They were child actors under immense pressure.
- They never formed a deep personal bond.
- They’ve maintained professional courtesy for decades.
- Neither has spoken ill of the other in recent years.
In short: It’s not a feud—it’s just indifference.
And in Hollywood, that’s more common than most realize.
FAQ Section
Q: Did Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb ever fight on set?
A: No verified reports or eyewitness accounts confirm physical or verbal fights. Tensions were subtle and mostly related to screen time and fan attention.
Q: Have they ever appeared together on talk shows?
A: They’ve been on the same panels (e.g., The Talk in 2011), but rarely engaged directly. Most appearances were group reunions with minimal one-on-one interaction.
Q: Is there video proof they don’t get along?
A: No. Behind-the-scenes footage from reunions shows polite, brief exchanges. Body language experts analyzing clips for Vanity Fair in 2021 noted “neutral, not hostile” cues.
Q: Why do people think they hate each other?
A: Media narratives, fan theories, and the natural human tendency to dramatize celebrity relationships—especially when the on-screen dynamic (Marcia vs. Jan) mirrors real-life sibling rivalry.
Q: Have either of them blocked the other on social media?
A: Neither has confirmed this, but the lack of follows or interactions suggests a conscious choice to maintain distance.
Q: Would they ever reconcile or become friends?
A: While possible, both are in their late 60s and seem content with separate lives. McCormick focuses on advocacy and memoirs; Plumb is a visual artist with little interest in Hollywood nostalgia.
Conclusion
So—does Maureen McCormick and Eve Plumb still hate each other? The answer is a clear no. What exists isn’t hatred, but a quiet, decades-long distance between two women who shared a childhood job but not a lifelong friendship.
Understanding this distinction matters. It reminds us that not every on-screen duo becomes best friends—and that’s okay. Their legacy isn’t defined by off-screen drama, but by the joy they brought to millions through The Brady Bunch.
If you found this deep dive helpful, share it with fellow Brady fans on Facebook or Twitter! And let us know in the comments: Do you think Marcia and Jan’s rivalry ever bled into real life?
Leave a Reply