When a Home Inspector Recommends Further Evaluation by a State Licensed Plumber

You’ve just received your home inspection report—and buried in the findings is a note that reads: “Further evaluation by a state licensed plumber recommended.” Your heart skips a beat. Is this a deal-breaker? A costly repair? Or just standard caution?

You’re not alone. Over 86% of home inspections uncover plumbing-related concerns, according to the American Society of Home Inspectors (ASHI). While inspectors are trained to spot red flags, they’re not licensed plumbers—and that’s exactly why they defer certain issues to professionals. In this guide, we’ll explain what this recommendation really means, when it’s urgent, and how to act wisely without overpaying or overlooking risks.

Why Do Home Inspectors Recommend Further Evaluation by a State Licensed Plumber?

Home inspectors follow strict standards—like those from InterNACHI or ASHI—that limit their scope. They can identify visible signs of trouble (e.g., leaks, corrosion, improper venting), but they cannot diagnose hidden problems, test water pressure beyond basic checks, or assess code compliance in depth.

“A home inspector’s job is to recognize potential issues—not to provide engineering or plumbing solutions,” says Michael Holmes, veteran contractor and host of Holmes Inspection. “When they say ‘call a plumber,’ it’s because something needs expert eyes.”

Common triggers for this recommendation include:

• Evidence of past or active leaks under sinks or near fixtures
• Unusual pipe materials (e.g., polybutylene, galvanized steel)
• Signs of poor drainage or sewer backups
• Water heater age or installation concerns
• Low water pressure with no obvious cause

These aren’t necessarily emergencies—but ignoring them could lead to mold, structural damage, or even insurance claim denials.

What Does “Further Evaluation” Actually Involve?

When a state licensed plumber steps in, they perform a deeper diagnostic than a general inspector ever could. Here’s what you can typically expect:

Step-by-Step Plumbing Evaluation Process

1. Visual & Physical Inspection
   The plumber examines accessible pipes, joints, valves, and fixtures—often using mirrors or cameras for tight spaces.
2. Pressure & Flow Testing
   Using calibrated gauges, they test water pressure (ideal: 40–80 psi) and flow rates to detect restrictions or leaks.
3. Drain & Sewer Scope (if needed)
   A small camera is snaked through drain lines to check for root intrusion, cracks, or bellies in the sewer line—common in homes over 20 years old.
4. Code Compliance Check
   They verify if recent plumbing work meets current local codes (e.g., proper venting, backflow prevention).
5. Written Assessment & Repair Estimate
   You’ll receive a clear report detailing findings, urgency level (low/medium/high), and cost estimates for fixes.

💡 Pro Tip: Always ask for the plumber’s license number and verify it via your state’s licensing board (or equivalent). In California alone, over 1,200 unlicensed plumbing complaints were filed in 2024.

Real-Life Example: A $500 Fix That Prevented $15,000 in Damage

In Portland, Oregon, first-time buyers Sarah and James were told their 1998 home needed “further evaluation by a state licensed plumber” due to slow kitchen drainage and a musty odor under the sink.

The inspector suspected a cracked waste line—but couldn’t confirm without invasive testing.

They hired a licensed plumber who performed a sewer scope and discovered a 3-inch crack in the main lateral line, caused by tree roots. Left unrepaired, this would’ve led to sewage backup and foundation moisture.

Cost to fix: $480 (trenchless epoxy lining).
Estimated future damage if ignored: $12,000–$18,000 (per National Association of Realtors data).

This case shows why the inspector’s note wasn’t alarmist—it was preventative.

Licensed Plumber vs. Handyman: Why Credentials Matter

Not all “plumbers” are equal. Only a state licensed plumber has:

• Passed rigorous exams on plumbing codes and safety
• Completed 4+ years of apprenticeship
• Carries liability insurance and bonding

Handymen may offer cheaper fixes—but if they misdiagnose or violate code, you could void your home warranty or face denied insurance claims.

For anything beyond unclogging a drain, always choose a licensed pro.

How to Choose the Right Plumber After an Inspection

Don’t just call the first name on Google. Follow these steps:

1. Verify License: Use your state’s official contractor license lookup tool (e.g., CSLB for California).
2. Check Reviews: Focus on recent Google or BBB reviews mentioning “inspection follow-up” or “diagnostic work.”
3. Ask About Diagnostic Fees: Many charge $75–$150 for evaluation—but often waive it if you hire them for repairs.
4. Request a Written Report: Not just a verbal summary. This protects you during negotiations with sellers.

⚠️ Avoid companies that pressure you into immediate repairs or refuse to provide itemized quotes.

FAQ Section

Q1: Does “further evaluation by a state licensed plumber” mean the house failed inspection?

No. Home inspections don’t have “pass/fail” outcomes. This note simply means a potential issue requires expert assessment beyond the inspector’s scope. It’s common—even in newer homes.

Q2: Who pays for the plumber—the buyer or seller?

It depends on your purchase agreement. Typically, the buyer pays for the initial evaluation, but you can negotiate for the seller to cover repairs or credits based on the plumber’s findings.

Q3: Can I skip the plumber if the issue seems minor?

Technically yes—but it’s risky. A small leak behind a wall can cause hidden mold growth within 24–48 hours (EPA). What looks minor may signal systemic failure.

Q4: How long does a plumbing evaluation take?

Most evaluations take 1–2 hours for a standard single-family home. Complex issues (e.g., sewer line diagnostics) may require a separate appointment.

Q5: Are all plumbing issues negotiable after inspection?

Not always. Cosmetic or maintenance items (e.g., dripping faucet) usually aren’t. But safety hazards, code violations, or major system defects (like corroded supply lines) are fair game for negotiation.

Q6: What if the plumber finds nothing wrong?

That’s still valuable! A clean bill of health gives you peace of mind—and documentation to share with your insurer or future buyers. Keep the report in your home file.

Conclusion

A note recommending “further evaluation by a state licensed plumber” isn’t a red flag—it’s a responsible checkpoint in your home-buying journey. By acting on it wisely, you protect your investment, avoid surprise costs, and ensure your home’s plumbing system is safe and efficient.

Don’t gamble with DIY fixes or unlicensed contractors. Invest in a qualified professional—it’s one of the smartest moves you’ll make as a homeowner.

Found this guide helpful? Share it with fellow homebuyers on Facebook, Pinterest, or Twitter! 🏡💧